Homemade Fly Spray That Actually Works: Natural Recipes for Horses, Livestock & Home

It’s the middle of summer. The sun is blazing. And the flies are relentless.

Your horse is stomping, swishing, twitching—miserable despite your best efforts. You reach for the commercial fly spray and realize two things:

1. You’re almost out.
2. That bottle cost $25, and it barely lasted two weeks.

Or maybe you’re sitting on your porch, trying to enjoy a quiet evening, but the flies have other plans. They’re circling your drink, landing on your arms, and generally making relaxation impossible.

Here’s the good news: You don’t need expensive, chemical-laden sprays to fight flies.

You can make highly effective fly spray at home, using simple ingredients you probably already have—for a fraction of the cost.

This guide gives you everything you need:

• The science behind why certain ingredients repel flies.
• Multiple recipes for horses, livestock, dogs, and home use.
• Safety guidelines for animals and humans.
• Application tips to maximize effectiveness.
• Troubleshooting for common problems.

Let’s send those flies packing.

---

I. Why Make Your Own Fly Spray?

The Problems with Commercial Fly Sprays

They’re expensive.
A quality fly spray runs $15–$30 per bottle. If you have multiple horses or livestock, you can easily spend hundreds of dollars per summer.

They contain chemicals you may want to avoid.
Many commercial sprays use pyrethroids, permethrin, or DEET. While effective, some horse owners prefer to avoid these—especially for animals with sensitive skin, pregnant mares, or young foals.

They don’t always work.
Flies develop resistance to chemical sprays over time. And some products simply don’t last long enough to justify the price.

You run out at the worst times.
Nothing is more frustrating than reaching for the spray bottle on a hot, fly-heavy day and finding it empty.

The Benefits of Homemade Fly Spray

Cost: $1–3 per batch vs. $15–30 for commercial products.

Control: You choose every ingredient. No mystery chemicals.

Customization: Adjust the formula for your animal’s skin sensitivity, your scent preferences, or the specific flies in your area.

Availability: Make it whenever you need it, with ingredients from your pantry and local stores.

Gentleness: Natural ingredients are often easier on sensitive skin and coats.

---

II. The Science: Why These Ingredients Repel Flies

Flies find their targets using a combination of:

• Carbon dioxide (from breathing)
• Body heat
• Sweat and moisture
• Manure and decaying organic matter
• Dark colors

Fly sprays work by masking these attractants or overwhelming the fly’s sensory receptors with scents they find offensive.

Here are the key ingredients and why they work:

Apple Cider Vinegar (ACV)

• Changes the scent profile of the skin and coat.
• Flies dislike the acidic, fermented smell.
• Adds shine and conditions the coat.
• Inexpensive and readily available.

Essential Oils (The Power Players)

Essential oils are the backbone of effective homemade fly spray. Different oils target different insects:

Oil	Why It Works	Best For
Citronella	Classic repellent; masks attractant scents	Flies, mosquitoes
Eucalyptus	Strong scent; antibacterial	Flies, gnats
Lavender	Calming + repellent; gentle on skin	Sensitive animals, general use
Peppermint	Intense scent; highly effective	Flies, gnats, mosquitoes
Tea Tree	Antifungal, antibacterial, repellent	Flies, skin issues
Lemongrass	Contains citral; very effective	Flies, mosquitoes
Cedarwood	Repels flies and ticks	Flies, ticks
Clove	Very potent; use sparingly	Heavy fly pressure
Rosemary	Mild repellent; pleasant scent	General use
Neem	Bitter, strong; excellent deterrent	Flies, gnats, ticks

Dish Soap

• Acts as a surfactant (helps oil and water mix).
• Helps the spray adhere to the coat instead of beading off.
• Use mild, unscented varieties.

Witch Hazel or Rubbing Alcohol

• Helps essential oils disperse evenly in water.
• Adds quick-drying properties.
• Mild astringent (can help with minor skin irritations).

Carrier Oils (Optional)

• Mineral oil, vegetable oil, or fractionated coconut oil.
• Adds shine and conditions the coat.
• Helps essential oils last longer on the skin.
• Makes the spray slightly “stickier” for longer protection.

---

III. Safety Considerations

Homemade fly spray is generally very safe, but there are important guidelines to follow.

Essential Oil Safety

• Always dilute essential oils. Never apply undiluted oils directly to skin or coat.
• Patch test first. Apply a small amount to a less sensitive area and wait 24 hours to check for reactions.
• Avoid sensitive areas. Keep spray away from eyes, nostrils, mouth, open wounds, and mucous membranes.

Animal-Specific Cautions

Horses: Generally tolerate most essential oils well. Watch for skin irritation, especially with tea tree or clove.

Dogs: Avoid tea tree oil (toxic in high concentrations) and citrus oils (can be irritating). Lavender, cedarwood, and lemongrass are generally safe.

Cats: Many essential oils are toxic to cats. Do not use homemade fly spray on or near cats. If you have barn cats, apply spray to horses in a separate area and allow it to dry before cats have access.

Pregnant or Young Animals: Some essential oils are not recommended for pregnant mares or very young foals. When in doubt, use a vinegar-only base or consult your veterinarian.

Skin Sensitivity

• If you notice irritation, hives, hair loss, or excessive itching, wash the area immediately and discontinue use.
• Try a gentler formula with reduced essential oil concentration.

Storage

• Store in a cool, dark place.
• Use within 2–4 weeks for best potency (essential oils degrade over time).
• Always shake well before use—ingredients will separate.

---

IV. Equipment & Supplies

What You Need

• Spray bottle: 16 oz or 32 oz for daily use; gallon garden sprayer for large herds.
• Measuring cups and spoons.
• Funnel (optional but helpful).
• Labels: Note the recipe, ingredients, and date made.

Where to Get Ingredients

• Apple cider vinegar: Any grocery store. Raw, unfiltered (with “the mother”) is ideal but not required.
• Essential oils: Health food stores, pharmacies, or online. Choose therapeutic-grade oils when possible.
• Dish soap: Any mild, unscented dish soap.
• Witch hazel: Pharmacy or grocery store.
• Carrier oils: Grocery store (vegetable oil, coconut oil) or online (fractionated coconut oil, mineral oil).

---

V. The Recipes

Recipe 1: Basic All-Purpose Fly Spray

For horses and livestock. Simple, effective, affordable.

Ingredients:

• 2 cups apple cider vinegar
• 2 cups water
• 1 tbsp mild dish soap
• 20–30 drops essential oil blend (see blends below)

Instructions:

1. Pour apple cider vinegar and water into a spray bottle.
2. Add essential oils.
3. Add dish soap last (to minimize foaming).
4. Cap and shake well.

Usage:

• Shake before each use.
• Spray liberally over coat, legs, belly, and chest.
• Use a cloth to apply to face and ears.
• Reapply every 2–4 hours or as needed.

---

Recipe 2: Heavy-Duty “Barn Strength” Fly Spray

For severe fly pressure or large animals.

Ingredients:

• 1 cup apple cider vinegar
• 1 cup water
• 1 cup witch hazel
• 2 tbsp vegetable oil or mineral oil
• 1 tbsp dish soap
• 40–50 drops essential oil blend (include clove and cedarwood for extra strength)

Instructions:

1. Combine all liquids in a large spray bottle or garden sprayer.
2. Add essential oils.
3. Add oil and dish soap.
4. Shake vigorously before each use.

Notes:

• The added oil helps the spray last longer on the coat.
• Clove is very potent—limit to 5–10 drops.

---

Recipe 3: Gentle Formula

For sensitive skin, foals, or horses prone to reactions.

Ingredients:

• 2 cups water
• 1 cup apple cider vinegar
• 10–15 drops lavender essential oil
• 5 drops chamomile essential oil (optional)
• 1 tsp dish soap

Instructions:

1. Combine all ingredients in spray bottle.
2. Shake well.
3. Patch test before full application.

Notes:

• Lavender and chamomile are gentle and calming.
• Good for young animals or those with known sensitivities.

---

Recipe 4: Dog-Safe Fly Spray

Gentle formula safe for most dogs.

Ingredients:

• 1 cup water
• 1 cup apple cider vinegar
• 10 drops lavender essential oil
• 10 drops cedarwood essential oil
• 5 drops lemongrass essential oil
• ½ tsp dish soap

Instructions:

1. Combine in spray bottle.
2. Shake well.
3. Spray on coat, avoiding face.
4. Use a damp cloth to wipe on ears.

Cautions:

• Avoid tea tree and citrus oils for dogs.
• Do NOT use on cats.

---

Recipe 5: Indoor / Patio Fly Spray

For humans and surfaces—not for animals.

Ingredients:

• 1 cup water
• ½ cup witch hazel
• 20 drops peppermint essential oil
• 20 drops eucalyptus essential oil
• 10 drops lemongrass essential oil

Instructions:

1. Combine in spray bottle.
2. Shake well.
3. Spray around doorways, windows, patio furniture, garbage cans, picnic tables.
4. Can be lightly misted on human skin (patch test first).

Notes:

• Refresh every few hours when used outdoors.
• Pleasant, fresh scent.

---

Recipe 6: Oil-Based Coat Conditioner + Fly Repellent

Longer-lasting protection with added shine.

Ingredients:

• 1 cup water
• ½ cup apple cider vinegar
• ¼ cup light mineral oil or fractionated coconut oil
• 1 tbsp dish soap
• 30 drops essential oil blend

Instructions:

1. Combine water, ACV, and carrier oil.
2. Add essential oils.
3. Add dish soap.
4. Shake very well before each use (oil will separate).

Notes:

• Leaves coat shiny and conditioned.
• Ideal for show horses or horses with dry coats.
• Requires vigorous shaking before every application.

---

VI. Essential Oil Blends

Mix and match these blends based on your needs and preferences.

Classic Repellent Blend

• 10 drops citronella
• 10 drops eucalyptus
• 5 drops lavender
• 5 drops peppermint

Calming Barn Blend

• 15 drops lavender
• 10 drops cedarwood
• 5 drops chamomile

Maximum Strength Blend

• 10 drops citronella
• 10 drops lemongrass
• 10 drops eucalyptus
• 5 drops tea tree
• 5 drops clove (use sparingly)

Fresh & Clean Blend

• 10 drops peppermint
• 10 drops rosemary
• 10 drops lavender

---

VII. Application Tips for Maximum Effectiveness

When to Apply

• Before turnout in the morning.
• Before riding or working.
• After bathing, once the coat is dry or damp-dry.
• Every 2–4 hours during peak fly season.

How to Apply

1. Shake the bottle vigorously. Ingredients separate—this is normal.
2. Spray liberally over the entire body: back, sides, belly, chest, legs, rump.
3. Use a cloth or sponge for the face, ears, and around the eyes. Never spray directly on the face.
4. Avoid eyes, nostrils, mouth, open wounds, and genital areas.
5. Don’t skimp. Homemade sprays work best with generous application.

Boost Your Results

Fly spray alone won’t solve a severe fly problem. Combine it with:

• Fly masks and fly sheets for physical protection.
• Leg wraps or boots for horses that stomp excessively.
• Fans in barns and stalls (flies are weak fliers).
• Manure management (flies breed in manure—remove it frequently).
• Fly traps and sticky tape around the barn.
• Fly predators (beneficial insects that eat fly larvae).

Storage Tips

• Store in a cool, dark place.
• Label with the recipe name, ingredients, and date made.
• Use within 2–4 weeks for best potency.
• Shake well before every single use.

---

VIII. Troubleshooting Common Problems

“It’s Not Working”

• Are you applying enough? Homemade sprays need liberal, thorough application.
• Are you reapplying often enough? Every 2–4 hours is typical—more often in heavy fly conditions.
• Try increasing essential oil concentration (within safe limits).
• Try a different oil blend. Some fly species respond better to certain scents.
• Combine with other fly control methods (masks, traps, fans, manure management).

“My Horse Hates the Smell”

• Reduce or eliminate peppermint or eucalyptus (strong, sharp scents).
• Increase lavender (calming, milder).
• Some horses prefer citrus-free blends.
• Experiment until you find a scent your horse tolerates.

“The Spray Irritated the Skin”

• Wash off immediately with plain water.
• Reduce essential oil concentration in your next batch.
• Switch to the gentle formula (Recipe 3).
• Always patch test before full application.

“The Ingredients Keep Separating”

• This is normal. Oil and water don’t mix permanently.
• Shake vigorously before every use.
• Add a bit more dish soap to help emulsify.
• Use witch hazel to help oils disperse more evenly.

---

IX. Cost Comparison: Homemade vs. Commercial

Commercial Fly Spray

• Price: $15–$30 per 32 oz bottle.
• Ingredients: Often includes pyrethroids, permethrin, or other chemicals.
• Availability: Requires a trip to the store or waiting for delivery.

Homemade Fly Spray

• Apple cider vinegar: ~$0.50 per batch
• Essential oils: ~$1–2 per batch (after initial investment in bottles)
• Dish soap: Pennies
• Water: Free

Total cost per 32 oz batch: $1–3

The Bottom Line

The initial investment in essential oils (typically $5–15 per bottle) pays for itself within a few batches. After that, you’re making fly spray for almost nothing.

And you get:

• Full control over ingredients.
• No harsh chemicals.
• The ability to make as much as you need, whenever you need it.

---

X. Quick Reference Tables

Recipe Summary

Recipe	Best For	Key Ingredients	Reapply
Basic All-Purpose	Horses, livestock	ACV, water, essential oils	2–4 hours
Heavy-Duty	Severe fly pressure	ACV, witch hazel, oil, strong EO blend	2–4 hours
Gentle Formula	Sensitive skin, foals	ACV, water, lavender, chamomile	2–4 hours
Dog-Safe	Dogs	ACV, water, lavender, cedarwood	2–4 hours
Indoor/Patio	Humans, surfaces	Water, witch hazel, peppermint, eucalyptus	2–3 hours
Oil-Based Conditioner	Show horses, dry coats	ACV, water, carrier oil, EO blend	3–5 hours

Essential Oil Quick Guide

Oil	Strength	Notes
Citronella	Strong	Classic fly repellent
Eucalyptus	Strong	Also antibacterial
Lavender	Mild	Calming, gentle
Peppermint	Strong	Very effective
Tea Tree	Moderate	Avoid on dogs/cats
Lemongrass	Strong	Excellent for flies
Cedarwood	Moderate	Also repels ticks
Clove	Very Strong	Use sparingly
Rosemary	Mild	Pleasant scent
Neem	Strong	Bitter, very effective

---

XI. Conclusion: Your Fly-Free Future Starts Now

You don’t need to spend a fortune on commercial fly sprays.

You don’t need to coat your animals in harsh chemicals.

You don’t need to watch helplessly as flies torment your horses, your dogs, or your family.

With a few simple ingredients—apple cider vinegar, essential oils, water, and dish soap—you can make effective, affordable, customizable fly spray that works.

Your Action Plan

1. Choose one recipe from this guide. The Basic All-Purpose formula is a great starting point.
2. Gather your ingredients. Most are available at your local grocery store or pharmacy.
3. Make your first batch. It takes less than 5 minutes.
4. Apply liberally and often. Shake well, spray generously, reapply every few hours.
5. Combine with other fly control methods for best results: masks, fans, traps, manure management.
6. Experiment. Try different essential oil blends. Adjust concentrations. Find what works best for your animals and your environment.

A comfortable horse is a happy horse.
A fly-free porch is a peaceful porch.
And a well-stocked spray bottle is your secret weapon all summer long.

Go make a batch. The flies won’t know what hit them.